3 Best Shoe Repair Shops in Fort Myers, Florida (2025 Guide)

Magic Shoe Repair is highly rated for its fantastic service and quality workmanship. Owners provide excellent customer care at reasonable prices, even offering rush services when needed. Customers appreciate the variety of shoe types they can repair, including orthotic items. The clean environment makes customers feel comfortable, with both owners contributing to an overall positive experience.

Solemate Shoe Repair is praised for its quality work and excellent customer service. However, there are concerns about shoes disappearing without the owner’s acknowledgment or return, leading to frustration among customers who have had their items stolen. Despite this issue, many still recommend Solemate due to swift repairs and kind treatment from owners Elmer and Lacey/Keith.

John B Morreale Sr runs Shoe Repair & More, where customers have praised his exceptional service and skill for fixing shoes, especially after hip replacement issues. His quick turnaround for custom leather work on dog equipment also made him stand out. Despite the small size of the Plaza location with tight parking, the store consistently received 5-star reviews for its fast services and reasonable prices.