5 Best Shoe Repair Shops in Sarasota, Florida (2025 Guide)

Smile Shoe Repair And Alterations offers top-notch repair and alteration services with exceptional attention to detail. Customers praise the speedy turnaround times, affordable prices, and outstanding customer service provided by Doo & Lee. After receiving items like torn Tecovas that looked like brand new upon pickup, multiple positive reviews highlight their quality workmanship and dedication to excellence in every aspect of their business.

Happy Feet Plus - Sarasota stands out with its exceptional service and knowledgeable staff who cater to customers' specific needs, whether for comfort or style. Customers appreciate the variety of styles available and the positive experience they have each time they visit. Their commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in their ability to accommodate a wide range of requests and bring joy to patrons and even their pets. Notably, Happy Feet Plus successfully resolved issues with manufacturers, further solidifying its reputation as an outstanding destination for footwear enthusiasts seeking personalized service and top-quality products.

Gulf Gate Shoe Repair seems to be highly regarded by customers for its skilled and experienced cobbler, Joe. Known for his honesty in assessing shoe repair options and his fair pricing, he has managed to earn multiple 5-star ratings over the years. From resoling favorite pairs of shoes like Timberland boots to providing quality work on high-end brands such as Christian Louboutin and Coach, Joe's service not only looks after but also preserves customers' treasured footwear well beyond their initial purchase. His commitment to customer satisfaction extends even to those who need shoe repairs quickly, ensuring they receive prompt yet competent care.

Arcadi’s Shoe Repair seems to be a highly regarded local business known for its exceptional shoe repair and polishing services. Customers often praise the friendly service provided by both the owner and employees, which includes quick turnaround times without compromise on quality. Despite some recent operational changes affecting new appointments, many long-term customers still recommend it for its commitment to excellent workmanship and customer care. However, there have been instances where service has varied in tone and friendliness, leading to mixed reviews from patrons.

Sergiy at Shoe and Leather, Inc., offers top-notch shoe and leather craftsmanship with consistent reliability and fast service. His new location on Reynolds Street has garnered high praise for its excellent workmanship and fair pricing. Customers appreciate his detailed attention to each repair job, ensuring complete satisfaction and quality. Known for exceptional work on various types of footwear, including Louboutin's and work boots, Sergiy's expertise has made him a go-to choice among locals who value his services greatly.