10 Best Shoe Repair Shops in Jamaica, New York (2025 Guide)

Romas shoe repair is highly regarded by customers for its professional and meticulous work on shoes, bags, belts, and other footwear items. The service consistently delivers excellent results at reasonable prices, earning multiple 5-star ratings. Despite some negative experiences, the majority of reviews highlight exceptional craftsmanship, friendly staff, and quick turnaround times. Whether it's repairing a vintage handbag or resoling boots, Romas seems to be one of the best options in the area for various shoe-related needs.

Alex Shoe Repair stands out with its friendly and knowledgeable staff who take pride in their craft. They offer professional shoe repair services at reasonable prices while providing detailed explanations before and after the work is done. Customers appreciate the owner's fair pricing and willingness to advise on proper care for their shoes, making Alex Shoe Repair a reliable choice for quality repairs. Despite one negative review citing slight condescension from staff, the majority of customers highly recommend this establishment for its excellent customer service and expertise in shoe repair.

Rni Shoe Repair is highly regarded for its exceptional service and quality work. Customers appreciate the quick turnaround times and affordable prices. The store’s owner shows great honesty and integrity, ensuring customers get reliable advice and maintenance on their footwear needs. Positive reviews highlight not just the craftsmanship but also friendly customer service that keeps returning customers loyal.

Teddy’s Shoe Repair has been a trusted name for years, known for providing high-quality repairs at reasonable prices. Customers appreciate his meticulous work and often exceptional results. With various services including resoling shoes, Teddy offers comprehensive solutions to address any shoe-related issues. Despite some recent challenges with customers being vocal about their preferences, the shop's positive reviews continue to support its reputation as one of the best in the business.

Michael’s Shoe Repair appears to be an establishment with a varied reputation. Some customers have had excellent experiences over the years, praising its excellent workmanship and long-standing service for various shoes and boots. However, there are also reports of rude treatment from staff, negative responsiveness regarding closures, and poor customer communication. Despite these issues, the shop continues to receive positive feedback, particularly from those who appreciate its meticulous repairs and dedication to quality over many years.

Linden Shoe Repair received mixed reviews from customers. Some found the service satisfactory and appreciated the quality of work performed, while others experienced issues including rude service, unclear communication about repairs needed, or inadequate understanding of shoe care needs. Despite these challenges, there are indications that the store can provide good repair services for more straightforward tasks if handled correctly. Overall, it seems Linden Shoe Repair has room to improve in terms of customer service and communication, which could lead to better experiences for future customers.

Shoe Repair Store has mixed reviews with some customers praising its quick and reliable service over the years, while others experienced issues ranging from poorly executed repairs to being charged repeatedly for services, suggesting a store that could be dishonest at times. Despite these criticisms, it seems to offer decent shoe repair, watch strap replacements, and battery changes alongside convenience store items, though signage needs adjustment as customers have pointed out subpar workmanship on some repairs.

Village Dry Cleaner & Repair Shoes has received mixed reviews, with some customers appreciating the detail-oriented work and fast service, while others found the tailoring lacking precision and had issues with their clothes not matching expectations. Despite these occasional drawbacks, there are clear signs that the establishment provides solid cleaning services, as indicated by positive feedback from six years ago. The recent 4-star review suggests a satisfactory experience overall, emphasizing speed and quality without highlighting exceptional detail work or specific clothing outcomes.

The shoe repair/maker/leatherman received mixed reviews. One customer was clearly dissatisfied, stating they were very disappointed with the service. Another reviewer praised the shop highly, not only for excellent repairs but also for creating exceptional shoes that cost quite a bit to purchase. This suggests that while there might be issues with some services or products, others can achieve remarkable results and craftsmanship that is worth the higher price tag.