5 Best Shoe Repair Shops in Staten Island, New York (2025 Guide)

Island Shoe Repair stands out among other shoe repair shops due to its long-standing reputation and the expertise of its owner and his wife. With a combined 35 years of experience, they offer professional yet friendly service that goes above expectations. Prices are reasonable, and their workmanship ensures shoes look as good or even better than new, making them a go-to for anyone needing quality shoe repair in the area. Their dedication to high-quality repairs has earned Island Shoe Repair a spot among customers' trusted resources.

Staten Island Shoe Repair appears to be an exceptional service offering tailored solutions for various footwear needs with skilled professionals providing top-notch repairs and restorations. Known for their quality workmanship and fair pricing, customers find the attention to detail and pleasant service at this establishment appealing. Despite being a small shop run by a lovely couple, it offers impressive results ranging from leather boots to everyday shoes needing adjustments or replacements, making it a go-to choice among locals and tourists alike.

Bement Shoe Hospital has garnered praise for its quality work and kind owner, who is appreciated by the local community for his skillful craftsmanship. Despite some recent issues with responsiveness and reliability, many customers still find it to be an essential place for repairing shoes due to its strong presence in West Brighton. However, there have been notable declines in service quality since the original owner's passing, leading to inconsistent hours and sometimes unexpected closures.

Roman Shoes on the Island Inc., appears to be a highly rated establishment with frequent patrons praising its owner for their excellent service and attention to detail. Despite occasional issues reported by some customers regarding pricing or completed work, many have consistently given it high ratings due to the quality of repairs and the overall positive experience they've had. The owner is considered very cordial, ensuring that repairs are done on time without causing undue stress. This reputation suggests Roman Shoes on the Island Inc. as a trusted choice for those needing their leather items fixed or resharpened.